39 Brunel Way, Thetford, Norfolk, IP24 1HP01842 777 760

What is appointment setting? (And why the meeting is only half the job)

What is appointment setting?

Appointment setting is the job of booking qualified sales meetings between a business and the people most likely to buy from it. Someone researches the target market, contacts decision-makers by phone, email and LinkedIn, checks they have a real need, and puts a meeting in the diary for a salesperson. It can be done by an in-house SDR or handed to an outsourced team.

That is the dictionary version. The real version involves a lot more voicemail.

A meeting in the diary is not a sale

Picture a sales director on a Monday morning. Her calendar is full, which feels like progress. There is the operations manager who agreed to a call mainly to get off the phone. There is the procurement lead who is “always happy to look at alternatives” and has been saying so, to everyone, since 2019. And somewhere in there is one person with a real problem, a budget and a deadline.

All three count as appointments. Only one is worth her morning. The difference between them is the whole craft of appointment setting, and it is why two agencies can both promise “20 meetings a month” and deliver completely different results.

How appointment setting works

  1. Research the market. Which companies buy what you sell, and which job titles make the decision. A good list does most of the work before anyone picks up the phone. This is where market research earns its keep, and why we think market research is the foundation of B2B sales.
  2. Make contact. Calls, emails and LinkedIn messages, usually several of each. One call rarely does it.
  3. Qualify. Is there a need, a budget, someone with authority and a timescale? We wrote about this in how to qualify sales leads.
  4. Book and confirm. A diary invite, a clear reason for the meeting and a reminder, so the buyer turns up knowing why they are there.
  5. Hand over. Notes on the company, the person and the problem, so the salesperson is not starting from scratch.

Where telemarketing fits in

Email and LinkedIn open doors, but most B2B appointments are still won on the phone. A call is where you find out who actually makes the decision, what they use now and whether the timing is right, and it is very hard to qualify someone properly through an inbox. That is why B2B telemarketing sits at the centre of nearly every appointment setting campaign.

Good telemarketing sounds less like a script and more like a well-informed conversation. The person calling knows your product, asks questions, listens to the answers and is perfectly happy to hear “not for us”. That last part matters more than it sounds. A telemarketer who can take a no gracefully is one the buyer will take a call from again in six months, when the answer might be different.

A good appointment, and a bad one

A good appointment is with someone who can buy, or who genuinely shapes the decision, has a problem you solve, and agreed to the meeting knowing what it was about. A bad one is a favour. You can usually tell which is which in the first five minutes, which is also roughly how long a bad one lasts.

The trouble with paying per appointment

Many appointment setting companies charge per meeting booked, and plenty of in-house teams set the same target for their reps. It sounds like the safest deal in the world: you only pay for results. The catch is in the word “results”. If the meeting is what gets paid for, the meeting becomes the goal, and the incentive is to book anybody, qualified or not, and to promise whatever gets them to say yes.

I have seen where that leads. We once took over a contract from another agency that had failed, and when I went back through their call data, the pattern was obvious. The reps were listening for pain and pouncing on it, even when the pain was something the client could not solve. Prospects had been promised help with problems that were nowhere near the scope, and in some cases solutions the client did not even sell. Every one of those calls counted as a booked appointment. Every one of them ended in an awkward first meeting and a buyer who now trusted the client a little less.

A meeting built on the wrong promise is worse than no meeting at all. There is more on this in our piece on pay per lead.

Why most appointments go nowhere

Here is the uncomfortable part. A first meeting is rarely where a B2B sale happens. 80% of sales are made between the 5th and 12th contact, and 48% of salespeople never follow up at all (National Sales Association). So a perfectly good appointment, with the right person and a real need, can quietly die because nobody chased the proposal. The buyer did not say no. They went on holiday, came back to 400 emails, and you were not one of the ones they answered.

That is why booking the meeting is only half the job. The other half is the follow-up: sending what was promised, chasing the quote, answering the awkward technical question, and calling again when the budget is finally signed off in March.

In-house or outsourced?

An in-house SDR learns your product inside out, but comes with a salary, management time and a few months of getting up to speed. An outsourced team starts sooner and brings people who do this every day, but needs a proper briefing to sound like you. For many companies with a small sales team, a sensible split is to outsource the outreach and keep the closing in-house. Others hand over the follow-up as well, because that is the part that never gets done when everyone is busy.

How we do it

Our appointment setting is done by experienced telemarketers, SDRs and Business Development Managers working under your company name. We are not paid per meeting, so nobody is tempted to book a favour or promise something you do not do. We qualify before we book, so your diary holds buyers rather than favours. And because a meeting only counts when it turns into an order, we can stay with the opportunity afterwards, follow-up and quotes included, as part of our outsourced sales service. You can see what that has produced in our case studies.

Quick answers

What does an appointment setter do?

Finds the right people at target companies, contacts them, checks they are a genuine prospect and books a meeting with your salesperson.

Is appointment setting the same as telemarketing?

Not quite. Telemarketing is the method, usually the main one. Appointment setting is the goal: a qualified meeting. Most campaigns now combine the phone with email and LinkedIn.

Should I pay per appointment?

Be careful. Paying per meeting rewards the number of meetings, not their quality, which can lead to unqualified bookings and promises your team cannot keep. A monthly fee with clear reporting keeps everyone focused on meetings that turn into orders.

How many appointments should I expect?

It depends on the size of your market, what you sell and how hard your buyers are to reach. Be wary of anyone who promises a fixed number before they understand your business.

Jonny Grimes
Written by
Jonny Grimes
Managing Director

Jonny is Managing Director of Hayward Miller. A commercial strategist who can also write, design and build, he took a start-up from a £60 box of stock to half a million pounds a year in sales before joining. He works across prospecting, market research, strategy and UK market entry for overseas firms.

LinkedIn
Connect on LinkedIn

We use cookies to make this website work and to improve your experience. See our Cookie Policy.